Whether it is MSP-based regime or DPPS, both are open-ended, susceptible to ever-increasing subsidy burden, and vulnerable to charge of violation under the WTO Two recent statements by the top brass give a clue as to how the Modi government intends to deal with pricing of farmers’ produce. First, addressing a conference on ‘Getting Agricultural Markets Right’ (July 6), Niti Aayog member Ramesh Chand proposed the adoption of deficiency price payment system (DPPS) as an alternative to the existing system of minimum support price (MSP). Next, the Union Agriculture Minister ruled out a legal guarantee for MSP. Under the existing system, agencies of the government, such as the Food Corporation of India (FCI), buy agri-produce, such as wheat, rice/paddy, coarse...
More Comments are closed
Articles
Eliminating freebies: Who will bell the cat?
Freebies are a recipe for financial bankruptcy; the only way to avoid it is to prohibit political parties from promising them Hearing a public interest litigation (PIL), filed by advocate Ashwani Dubey, seeking directions against ‘freebies’—a euphemism for benefits distributed by political parties using public money for garnering votes—on August 3, 2022, the bench of Chief Justice of India NV Ramana and Justices Krishna Murari and Hima Kohli sought suggestions from all stakeholders. The stakeholders include beneficiaries and the people who are opposing these freebies, besides the government as well as organisations such as Niti Aayog, Finance Commission, RBI and Opposition parties, etc. The suggestions have been sought on the composition of a committee which can go into the issue...
More Comments are closed
Saving fertiliser subsidy with DBT
The Government should stop routing subsidies through manufacturers and give these as direct benefit transfer Splurge in fertiliser subsidy in the last three years is giving jitters to policy makers, especially the Union finance ministry, which has to foot the bills. Fertiliser subsidy amounts to payments made to manufacturers or importers to cover the excess of the cost of production/import and distribution over a low maximum retail price (MRP, the price asked by the Union Government to charge from the farmers). These payments are under two broad categories viz. (i) urea, main source of nitrogen or ‘N’ supply; (ii) phosphate or ‘P’ and potash or ‘K’ fertilizers – commonly known as non-urea fertilizers – popular fertilizer in this category being...
More Comments are closed
GST compensation can’t be perpetual; States must be prudent
The disruption caused by the pandemic is a thing of the past as tax collection rebounded during 2021-22 In its 47th meeting, the GST (Goods and Services Tax) Council held on June 28/29, 2022, at least a dozen finance ministers and other ministers of the states demanded that compensation for losses due to implementation of the GST should be extended. In the follow up to the unveiling of the GST by the Modi government, ‘The Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016’, that introduced the GST from July 1, 2017, the Union government also introduced ‘The GST Compensation Act, 2017’. It provides for compensation to the States for five years (2017-18 to 2021-22) for the loss of revenue. The...
More Comments are closed
Financial discipline a must for states
The Centre has to crack the whip on growing trend of states going for excessive borrowings else it could lead to a major financial crisis In recent years, indiscriminate borrowings by entities of the state governments, leveraging guarantees, has raised alarm bells. In June, 2022, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) lambasted banks, mostly public sector banks (PSBs), for lending to such entities based on the escrow of the states’ future revenue streams or using collectorates and courts as security. The RBI sought a review of such lending practices by the bank boards and reported compliance by September, 2022. The Union Finance ministry was more emphatic, seeking an end to the practice. The warning is a follow up to a...
More Comments are closed
Let free market discover the price!
Deficiency price payment may be way forward as agri market forces are better placed to judge the value of agri products Addressing a conference on ‘Getting Agricultural Markets Right’ (July 6, 2022), Ramesh Chand, who is a Member of the Niti Aayog, proposed the adoption of deficiency price payment system (DPPS) as an alternative to the existing dispensation of procurement of crops from the farmers at minimum support prices (MSPs). What is the problem with the MSP-based regime? How will DPPS help in alleviating it? Under the existing system, agencies of the government like the Food Corporation of India (FCI) buy agri-produces such as wheat, rice/paddy, coarse cereals, from farmers at the MSP and distribute at a subsidized price of...
More Comments are closed
Fuel crisis: Government must shed adhocism
Currently, E&P firms are allowed to sell their crude at parity with its international price To deal with the fuel crisis, recently the Modi government has deregulated sale of domestically-produced crude oil; and imposed a cess, or windfall tax, of Rs 23,250 per tonne on crude oil and a special additional excise duty (SAED) of Rs 6 per litre. and Rs 13 per litre on exports of petrol and diesel respectively. On July 20, the SAED on petrol was removed and on diesel was cut to Rs 11 per litre. On on one hand, it expects exploration and production (E&P) companies like Oil India Limited (OIL), Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC), and Cairn Oil and Gas to increase the...
More Comments are closed
Electricity Bill: Where is the spark?
After dilution of its key provisions, the Electricity Bill, 2021, falls short of reform objectives In the draft Electricity (Amendment) Bill or EAB, 2021, proposing amendments to the Electricity Act, 2003 introduced in February last year, the Narendra Modi-led NDA Government intended to bring about two transformative reforms — de-licensing of the electricity distribution business and direct benefit transfer (DBT) of subsidy. Delicensing of the distribution business aims to bring in competition, and give the consumer power to choose suppliers (or “open access”). Even as the Union ministry of power prepares to table a Bill in the upcoming Monsoon session (2022) of Parliament, both the provisions have been dropped. Under the extant arrangements, an overwhelming share of power generated by public...
More Comments are closed
Hydrocarbons may give India energy freedom
Windfall tax on oil firms is justified; a robust ecosystem for hydrocarbons can give India the much-needed relief Amid disruption in the global supply chain and steep spike in the international crude prices, the Union Cabinet last week took two major decisions pertaining to the oil sector—deregulation of the sale of domestically-produced crude oil and imposing a cess or windfall tax of Rs 23,250 per tonne on crude oil and a special additional excise duty (SAED) of Rs 6 per litre, Rs 13 per litre and Rs 6 per litre on exports of petrol, diesel, and jet fuel respectively. The Covid-19 pandemic and the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war have acutely affected the global supply chains, besides giving legs to the prices...
More Comments are closed
MC12: Advantage developed countries
War against Covid-19 has to embrace all the three critical dimensions: testing, tracking, and treatment At the recent 12th Ministerial Conference (MC12) at the World Trade Organisation (WTO) headquarters in Geneva (June 12-17), it was advantage developed countries – the US, the European Union, the UK, Australia etc., — all the way. The Indian delegation led by Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal occupied the centre-stage steering negotiations in all key areas but the outcome was not in their favour. First, India went to MC12 demanding a Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Waiver for all Covid-related therapeutics and diagnostics, besides vaccines. Against this, the MC-12 granted a patent waiver (albeit ‘temporary’ and ‘limited’) only for Covid-19 vaccines which will allow India to authorise...
More Comments are closed